Do a couple of irons too, test a 9, 7 and 5 iron from 4 or 5 different popular clones and their OEM twin. Thank you. Not the muscle blade. Restore formatting, Written by L Mayhew 2007 . These shafts do perform differently from one another. In no way do I have the means to measure every single piece of equipment to find out how many clones or OEMs were outside of tolerance but Im willing to bet its not as much of a disparity as some people would lead you to believe. . Obviously, many big brand clubs are really good and almost always lead the trends in golf technology (maybe not originally came up with all of the ideas). Are shafts or heads manufactured to a large (+-) tolerance with the (-) tolerance being the norm or are the parts manufactured to close tolerances? The 2nd tier often makes some of the mid-size golf companies that a lot of you play but they also make some of the top components and clones for companies like. You were basing most of your information on PssstWanna buy some clubs?, which only talks about Integra and Trophy Sports (owned by the same family). I found that both sets hit almost exactly the same distance with the same loft, atleast I cannot notice any difference. They might could provide you with design answers/informationyou might have. But the same thing can be said about some of the name brand models as well. It states that Tom Wishon actually designed the first titanium driver head in the early ninetys way before any OEM had one on the market. Driver: TM Original One 11.5* set to 11*, Aldila NV75 X, 43.5" -or- SpeedZone, HZRDUS Black 75 6.5, 43.5" Thanks guys, have fun. The 2nd tier often makes some of the mid-size golf companies that a lot of you play but they also make some of the top components and clones for companies like Golfsmith, Hireko and Diamondtour. Great point Bob. GigaGolf offers True Temper shafts as their standard shaft and you can upgrade to different shafts and grips of your choosing. Ive used their 302 model iron for years now and just recently compared their performance against several of the leading irons on the market. Maltby has been around since the mid 1970's I believe. Once the swing is dialed in, then perhaps rewarding yourself with an expensive set of clubs is a great goal. I paired that up w a recoil pull and I love that club, it's my go-to for tee shots if driver isn't behaving. He is a Callaway Master Fitter and serves on the National Board of Callaway Fitters. Most of us who choose to play clones most likely at some point played name brand clubs. Okay, you somewhat mixed it up. Or youre the website that would love to write an article like this, but worry about the repercussions you might feel from an OEM advertiser. First let me say that I am 88 years old and have been playing Hireko golf clubs, particularly their THRIVER for 8 years. I have seen a few really bad Adams, Callaway, Cobra, Nike, and Ping clubs. You will receive personalized attention from the initial interview through product delivery. You will receive personalized attention from the initial interview through product delivery. The point of his article, as with any good marketing person, the tolerances of his product offerings were much tighter than the competition. Love them. And, as they acquire them they would tweak the designs to what is available today. I started getting their catalogs in the 80's and buying from them. It's a combination driver and fairwaywood. Play like poor mans Taylor Made P790. If we simply look at the raw averages we see that the Clone was actually more accurate! Hmmmwe think maybe theres a chance it might.Lets go to the lab! What I will say is that I glued together a few of their sets for buddies and lofts, lies and head weights are not spot on. So bottom line dont leave this subject here Golf Spy please do a test of clone irons! A lot of the posts in this thread are opinions, I prefer facts. (LOVE THE MILITARY CAMO BAG THEY HAVE only $59 too ;). Its almost laughable to make those type of statements! I worked in manufacturing for over 50 years and watched all kinds of products being manufactured from high quality aircraft bolts to electronic equipment to toys. That was a great article, anything that can spark so much emotion and debate is a good thing. It is your decision and right (for the time being) to buy a Clone/Knock-Off. I met him in person at an Lpga event in Atlantic city (he is the caddie/boyfriend of Sara Brown. Pinhawks are a separate entity, and they are pretty good. To say that a consumer has no responsibility is, well sad. All those statements do is hurt the component biz. All you did was test one club head pretty worthless really. Pinemeadows offers a lower end shaft as their standard, but you can upgrade too. Some, like Frank Thomas (former USGA Tech. Just a quick note to say i recently decided to take up golf. Having never played before i cant say too much but my mates whove played for years were impressed after trying them out. I would like to see the stock shafts for each club tested. Hireko is also an authorized reseller of Tim not only is a popular fitter but one of the most sought-after instructors. Complete junk notwithstanding its all about your swing. Jethro Liou is an expert in the knockoff business. I actually built some Wishon/Sterlings (single length collaboration between Tom Wishon/Jacob Bowden) at multiple lengths (i.e. As with our test of the Shotmaker, shafts were spined and FLOd. Cool. I worked for Arnold Palmer Golf back in the dark ages and built and sold clones and knock offs for 20 years. And also just so you know OEMs have almost always tried to prevent foundries from doing clone products at the same foundriesbut it happens everyday. (Yes that myth is true), There are basically 3-tiers of golf club manufacturing to make it simple. I certainly believe there is little difference in shot results from an overall performance. Yup, found that article. Its in the hole! Carl Spackler. Unless its done in jestof course. Learn more about Tim. Its in the hole! They are concentrating on Counterfeits and Copies, but again, Clones and Knock Offs are part of the same problem. So if the name-brand companies are fine with it, why would anyone, that decides to save money on purchasing similar product, be doing the wrong thing? However: the result you provided does tell us that one club seems not twenty-five percent better to justify the cost difference, but as with a new suit, cost is a factor to most people some believing the lower cost buys the good-enough quality and some believe they deserve the best, and humans equate best with price. With respect to backspin the numbers are incredibly close. There is so many aspects to playing this game, and so many different things that can effect how we play. If your not a sub 10 handicap chances are you arent good enough to fully take advantage of the clubs your hitting. Well.i found the clone world years ago,.and love em. Built my wife an Acer driver in 14*loft, she loves it. Sent from my SM-N960U using MyGolfSpy mobile app. Display as a link instead, From tee to green and everything in-between, Hireko offers a wide array of golf clubs for players of all ages and abilities. Hes a Cinderella story. I have a set of irons by Affinity. He built mostly dynacraft stuff, so I got a lot of odd components from the 80s. If you choose to purchase new golf clubs from us, your clubs will be custom-built to your specifications at prices comparable to major online retailers. . My guess is that you have predetermined that a clone has to be an inferior product? The lofts of the warp speed heads closely match the EDEL one length irons, so the distances between clubs is easily accomplished using back weighting. After school he would make cold calls for his father, Ren-Jei (R.J.) Liou, asking pro shops and discount stores if they wanted to order from his line of clubs. I no longer build drivers or sets, because I was checking iron set I received and the individual weights varied as much as 12 -15 grams which can be huge. Great review! Reshafting These services usually take 5 to 7 days, as we have to order I cant say Ive chased the next new thing, only last year did I move the a 460 driver, of course I had to build three. it is the best $100 youll ever spend in your golf life.no club will be right if you dont build to your stats, dont go by some charts, too many variables) it amazes me what quality you can get for so little,.i buy from most,.but like Diamond tour, and ingolf(tracy), very pleasent service. with hosel weight bore allows assembly to any single length between 35.5 and 37.5 while still being able to achieve a reasonable range of swingweight/MOI (depending on shaft weight and grip weight), Looking for more consistency from your iron game? Tony is the Editor of MyGolfSpy where his job is to bring fresh and innovative content to the site. Happy now. Someone else designed it, so theyre going to laser copy it, skip the R&D, use cheaper material, spend nothing on advertising the new design, and take money from a certain consumer segment. I had them custom fitted senior flex shafts. MyGolfSpy, INC. All rights reserved. The clubs were built with FST 90 regular tip trimmed shafts for a 6 iron. SWIFT) In 1997 R.J. Liou reached a settlement with Callaway. It was promoted as a driver and fairway wood combination. That experiment ended due to never being able to gap the clubs well, especiallythe short ironsand wedges. Spin While many manufacturers are promoting less spin off the driver, the truth of the matter is that the distance equation is far more complex than less spin = more yards. How many 20 plus handicaps do you know that spend hundreds of dollars each year ensuring they have the latest name brand technology in their bag? Make yourself aware. Most companies are trying to get it right with their stock shafts. It is a matter of time and money right now. Speaking of non OEM brands, which of the following irons will be best quality for play- Maltby, Wishon,, Alpha, Kzg, Hireko, etc. (circa 2013)https://mygolfspy.com/ultimate-review-acer-xs-driver/. I know of at least 2 touring pro who wanted to be sponsored by KZG and use their clubs. In addition to his editorial responsibilities, he was instrumental in developing MyGolfSpy's data-driven testing methodologies and continues to sift through our data to find the insights that can help improve your game. Strong lofts with forgiving mishits and incredible feel. Iron 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,Pitching Wedge,Approach Wedge,Sand Wedge or, Set with Graphite/Steel Shafts for Right Handed Golfers, Iron 2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,PW for Men & Women,Right Handed, Set for Men & Women (4,5,6,7,8,9,P,A,S) or Individual Iron 7,Left/Right Handed,37.5 Inch, 7 for Golfer Slower Swing Speeds, Reduced Strain on The Old Elbows and Wrists, Help Shots Go Farther, Men & Women Right Handed, Iron Set, Mens Right Hand 5-6-7-8-9-PW-GW, (2&3) Right or Left Hand Steel Shaft Regular Flex. Ball: Wilson Staff Duo Professional, Bridgestone Tour B-RXS, Callaway Chrome Soft. Dynacraft was next with Golfsmith last. I like the test, but IMO for more accuracy the shafts need to be tested with the club. How is the overall health of golf these days? IMO, no they do not. who would do that ? Taylormade bought out Adams. What proved to be reality for our testers is that despite similar performance, thedifferencesin the subjective categories (in this particular case) are potentially enough to suggest that for some there is indeed $200 worth of improvement to be found in the Burner Tour. Great read! All of the testers agreed that in terms of sound and feel, the clone is miles behind the real deal. Thats the sound of the hammer hitting the nail right on the head. Giga provides a great club for the average golfer at an affordable price. Questions? Note: The FTC considers the terms Clone and Knock-Off to be identical. Golfworks (Malby) and Wishon Golf (Tom Wishon) are two of the best. After all, there is no way on this green earth that a clone with an assembled price of less than $100 ($59 head only) could outperform a club from a popular golf company with an initial price tag of $300 right? Cell: 586-489-9735. usually its the loft and lies that are way off but then you have the improper weighting/balance and the occasional head that goes flying down the range . Custom Golf Clubs - Hireko Golf Their price is very reasonable but that doesn't effect the quality. Personally I would love to see a test of these irons matched up against the real McCoy. Some features of a driver, its head size, for instance, cannot be protected, but others can. . Same way with a bad club. Looks As you might expect the Burner looks much more refined. Actually liked the longer length distance gapping in those but could not dial in shorter length club distancegapping. Theymay not be fancy looking and after 8 years playing with them over 150 days each seasonin Alaska the paint is scraping off the titanium club head a bit, but that doesn't effect the way it plays. And some use the exact same molds. It does however cost money to get started in golf. http://www.diamondtour.com/golf-bags.html, http://www.pinemeadowgolf.com/golf-clubs/accessories/ Now counterfeit producers is a different story. I agree with most of that. Give me a web site that shows the difference names of club components and the quality of the components so I can make an informed decision so that I dont have to rely on a manufacturer who has advertised his name to be number one. You cannot paste images directly. If a manufacturer doubled his price on his highest priced clubs (lets call them X) making no other change except price (lets call the inflated priced clubs Y) and taged the Y clubs ultra sales would probably increase for both clubs, some wanting the very best because theyre priced higher, and some saying This club looks just as good and I can buy it for half the price of the other! The mental human factor.
Graphic Designer Jobs Boston, What Did Christina Desantis Die Of, Taking A Bath Without Sleep Can Cause Death, Which Zodiac Sign Has The Least Friends, Articles H